The Samovar

What is torture?
October 3, 2006, 5:46 pm
Filed under: Politics, Terrorism, Torture

The US Congress has passed the Military Commissions Act, effectively legalising torture. Their technique is basically to redefine what they are doing as not-torture, a time honoured technique of repressive governments. (The Strijdom government who created Apartheid in South Africa pulled off the trick by basically getting a whole lot of stooge judges to reinterpet “you may not disenfranchise all the black people” to mean “you may disenfrachise them”.)

Much of the discussion of this Act focusses on the nitty gritty details of their definitions of torture, and what they mean. For example, about whether or not “waterboarding” counts as torture. This discussion is very important, particularly in highlighting what it is exactly they propose to do in the most graphic way possible, so that people understand it. But, it seems to me that a crucial point has been missed. However you define torture, if you are allowed to do something to someone that makes them give up their most cherished secrets against their will and their strongest beliefs, then you must be doing something so horrible to them that the pain involved is worse than going against everything you believe. This level of pain must be considered torture.

In other words, if “interrogation techniques” are to be effective, they must count as torture. If they weren’t torture, they wouldn’t work.

Comments Off on What is torture?

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: